image description
Market Trends

The Storage Gap: Why Half the U.S. Grid Is Missing Out on the BESS Boom

6 min read

BESS deployment across U.S. power markets is showing sharp regional divergence. While western markets are advancing rapidly, those in the east remain at an early stage.

A recent report finds the gap is driven by complex market rules and varying levels of renewable penetration that limit some regions while enabling others to grow.

Five years into the BESS boom, grid operators in PJM, MISO, SPP, and the Southeast have been slow to adjust market designs to accommodate the unique characteristics of BESS, as reflected in significant deployment disparities compared with leading markets such as ERCOT and CAISO. The result is constrained growth for a technology that supports grid reliability and renewable integration. This comes as eastern grids face a critical need for additional generating capacity, which BESS is well positioned to provide due to its relatively fast deployment, lower cost, and operational flexibility.

The report, “The Storage Gap,” by the public interest group GridLab, finds no single barrier behind the disparity. Instead, it highlights multiple constraints across energy, capacity, and ancillary services markets, as well as interconnection queues and procurement rules. These constraints are especially problematic for BESS because the technology relies on multiple revenue streams beyond electricity sales to remain economically viable. This strategy, known as revenue stacking, includes participation in capacity markets and the ability to shift between ancillary services and energy markets based on changing grid conditions.

“Texas and California, two very different states, have proved that grid-scale battery storage can effectively tackle rising peak demand, yet nearly half of the United States grid is not maximizing the benefits of storage,” said GridLab Executive Director Ric O’Connell. “This begs the question of why Eastern markets, facing unprecedented load growth and rising consumer costs, are so far behind in storage deployment when they urgently need flexible sources of power.”

A key economic issue in ancillary services markets in eastern grids, including PJM, is that rules prevent suppliers from fully incorporating operating and opportunity costs into their offers for reserve products, such as ramping products and real-time operating reserves. This limitation is particularly detrimental to BESS, as opportunity costs – the profit forfeited by dispatching now instead of later at potentially higher prices – are a fundamental driver of marginal costs. According to the report, this limitation reflects legacy market designs from a period when ancillary services were dominated by thermal generators with near-zero marginal costs. Failure to account for these costs can reduce revenues and undermine the economic viability of BESS.

Like ancillary services, capacity markets are a key revenue source for BESS, particularly as rising demand from data centers has pushed capacity prices to record levels. However, the report identifies several drawbacks. First, capacity prices are determined through auctions held every one to three years, depending on the market, and clearing prices can be highly volatile. Second, resources that clear the auction typically secure payments for only one to three years, which is significantly shorter than the operational life of a generation asset.

BESS faces additional uncertainty in capacity markets, particularly in PJM, due to capacity accreditation – the process that determines a resource’s contribution to system reliability and its eligible capacity revenues. In PJM, a four-hour BESS system – the minimum duration required to participate – is currently credited at about 60% of its nameplate capacity. This is expected to decline to as low as 23% by 2035, reflecting projected changes in the resource mix and load profile. This reduction directly lowers expected revenues.

By contrast, in ERCOT, BESS is not constrained by a capacity market and can operate with shorter-duration systems, such as two-hour assets, reducing upfront CAPEX. “Recent years have seen significant revisions to capacity accreditation across PJM, MISO, and SPP,” the report states. “These methods may be subject to further changes over time, creating risk for BESS investors and lenders relying on capacity market revenue streams.”

BESS also faces challenges in energy markets, which can represent the largest share of revenue through intraday price arbitrage. In ERCOT, BESS can adjust its strategy in near real time, with decisions made every five minutes. In contrast, while dispatch in PJM also occurs every five minutes, operators must commit to strategies earlier and have less flexibility to adjust throughout the day. CAISO shares some of these constraints in its real-time market but offsets them through state-led procurement and resource adequacy mechanisms. BESS performs best when it can quickly switch between revenue streams, and structural limitations can lead to suboptimal outcomes and weaker project economics.

“This mismatch between fixed offers and dynamic costs results in a higher risk of inefficient dispatch, which can raise overall system costs and degrade the profitability of BESS,” the report states.

ERCOT and CAISO are the leading markets for BESS deployment, despite having different market designs. A key common factor is higher levels of grid constraints, often driven by renewable penetration. The resulting price volatility creates opportunities for BESS to capture value by charging during low or negative price periods and discharging when prices are high. In contrast, many eastern markets have lower wind and solar penetration. While these markets often include capacity payments, the lack of sufficient price volatility in energy markets limits the attractiveness of BESS investment. These structural differences have led to significantly different outcomes. With 9 GW of installed capacity, representing about 11% of peak load, ERCOT has deployed nearly ten times more BESS than PJM, MISO, SPP, and the Southeast combined. Early growth in ERCOT was driven by strong ancillary services revenues and energy arbitrage opportunities linked to high renewable penetration.

In CAISO, the national leader, BESS deployment has been driven primarily by state-led procurement and resource adequacy frameworks, enabling capacity to exceed 14.5 GW, or nearly 38% of peak demand.

“There is no single regulatory ‘silver bullet’ that will expand BESS deployment in these regions to the levels seen in California (CAISO) and Texas (ERCOT),” the report concluded. “However, a range of reforms at both the RTO and state level could meaningfully reduce barriers and improve the investment environment for storage.”

 

Navigating ERCOT & PJM Clean Power Markets?

Learn how Pexapark’s price intelligence helps you spot market opportunities and act with confidence. Book a demo >