image description
Market Trends

U.S. Supreme Court’s Strike Down of ‘Liberation Day’ Tariffs Provides False Hope to Import-Reliant U.S. Renewable Industry

6 min read

Supreme Court overturns “Liberation Day” tariffs, but replacement duties and trade restrictions keep cost pressure on U.S. solar and BESS supply chains.

The U.S. Supreme Court (SCOTUS) struck down President Donald Trump’s sweeping “Liberation Day” tariffs, initially signaling major relief for the import-reliant U.S. renewable energy industry. However, that optimism ultimately proved fleeting.

In a 6-3 decision on 20 February, the high court ruled that the administration’s tariffs enacted under the International Emergency Economic Powers Act (IEEPA) were unconstitutional. The order delivered a decisive blow to the White House’s protectionist policy, which had disrupted global trade by applying levies to nearly every country. For U.S. importers of solar and BESS subject to high duties, however, the victory was short-lived.

While the SCOTUS decision removed the broad IEEPA-based tariffs – a general cost adder on many imports – it leaves several sector-specific trade measures unchanged. These include Section 301 tariffs on Chinese goods, including stationary batteries and some battery inputs as well as solar products; solar antidumping and countervailing duty (“AD/CVD”) cases, which remains a major driver for module pricing/sourcing; and Section 232 tariffs on steel and aluminum, which affects balance-of-plant costs. Additional restrictions on solar and BESS imports from so-called prohibited foreign entities (PFE), particularly China, further constrain supply chains. Finally, new and forthcoming trade deals negotiated under the threat of the now-defunct “Liberation Day” duties may require renegotiation, risking further disruptions to global trade.

Adding further uncertainty for the clean energy industry, President Trump quickly announced new tariffs of up to 15%, under  Section 122 of the Trade Act. These tariffs function as a short-term across-the-board cost layer on many imported clean energy components. Notably, the new tariffs apply uniformly across all countries and are subject to a 150-day limit. In some cases, the 15% cap matches the previous rate, while in others it reduces the effective burden. On March 4, Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent confirmed that tariffs on global imports would rise to 15% within days.

“Project developers have already had to deal with tax guidance coming out about how to access U.S. federal tax credits, which are complicated and require supply chain sourcing to shift around,” said Matthew Hales, an associate on BloombergNEF’s (BNEF) trade and supply chains team. “They’ve now got these tariff rate changes, and I think what’s really key is that this uncertainty is going to continue going forward as well.”

Consequently, project developers are likely to continue embedding risk premiums in their PPAs and BESS offtake arrangements in the current environment. These reflect not only the volatility of tariff policy, but also an administration that appears determined to establish new trade regimes similar to the IEEPA framework to restrict imports while also reducing federal subsidies and loans that would have spurred domestic manufacturing alternatives for solar and BESS components.

Because tariffs and supply chain costs are core drivers of a project’s levelized cost of energy (LCOE) – the minimum price per unit of electricity required for a project to raise financing and generate an acceptable equity return – persistent uncertainty and cost inflation ultimately translate into higher PPA or BESS offtake prices. This is especially true for solar modules, which account for about 35% of total project costs, and BESS components, which represent 40% to 50% of total project cost. The consequences extend well beyond capital expenditures, however. Persistent trade barriers threaten to reduce the overall supply of new solar equipment, slow down already-congested interconnection queues, and limit renewable capacity growth across the country.

For BESS developers hoping for a pricing reprieve, the replacement tariffs at the 15% level remove any expected rate reductions for major BESS suppliers in Japan and South Korea. As for China, which supplied 40% of the U.S. market in the first half of 2025, importers would see a roughly 5-percentage-point reduction under the new 15% rate. However, strict PFE rules severely restrict how much U.S. developers can actually import from Chinese manufacturers, rendering the tariff reduction largely irrelevant. Separately, the administration has recently imposed Section 301 tariffs on solar panels and other items from China and may attempt to invoke other mechanisms, such as Section 338, to impose further levies. Finally, the Trump administration recently announced a countervailing duty (CVD) on solar imports from India, Indonesia, and Laos over allegations of unfair manufacturing subsidies, with rates on Indian imports reaching 126%. According to BNEF, these three nations accounted for nearly 60% of U.S. solar-module imports in the first half of 2025.

While the U.S. has previously used tariffs to counter alleged trade distortions, rates have recently surged. The trade-weighted average tariff on imported solar modules reached 195% in July 2025, up from just 13% a year earlier, according to BNEF. BESS tariffs jumped to 31% from 8% over the same period. The trade-weighted average tariff is the average import duty applied by the U.S., weighted by each nation’s share of total monthly imports.

The Supreme Court did not address whether companies could recover tariffs already collected under the previous regime, leaving uncertainty over potential refunds totaling billions of dollars.

 

Navigating ERCOT & PJM Clean Power Markets?

Learn how Pexapark’s price intelligence helps you spot market opportunities and act with confidence. Book a demo >